Warren Buffett once famously said, “If I ever get elected president, I will never claim credit for anything the market does.”
With the midterm elections now behind us, everyone seems to have a prediction about what the stock market will do next, and it’s usually based on whether their preferred candidates won or lost.
In the days following the election’s resounding win for Democrats, we witnessed a significant selloff in the stock market, particularly among technology and artificial intelligence companies. Although the market has recovered some of its losses, as I write this on Monday, November 16, the tech-heavy Nasdaq remains down almost 3.5% since Election Day.
With some Democratic candidates campaigning against the rapid expansion of data centers and calling for tighter restrictions on AI companies, it’s understandable why investors might believe these businesses are likely to be harmed by the shift in political power.
This is hardly the first time investors have attempted to predict an industry’s future profitability based on which political party holds power. Unfortunately, history would suggest those predictions are often wrong.
Consider what happened following Donald Trump’s surprising presidential victory in 2016. Renewable energy stocks declined sharply as investors feared his administration would eliminate government incentives and enact policies favoring fossil fuels. By the end of that year, the iShares Global Clean Energy ETF had fallen nearly 9% from Election Day.
Yet those fears proved largely overblown. Within approximately three months, renewable energy stocks had recovered their losses, and by the end of 2017, that same ETF was trading nearly 8% above its Election Day value.
Healthcare stocks experienced a similar reaction, particularly among hospital operators. Immediately following Trump’s election, shares of major hospital operators plunged, with HCA Healthcare declining approximately 11% and Tenet Healthcare falling more than 20%. Investors feared Republicans would repeal the Affordable Care Act, potentially leaving hospitals with more uninsured patients and unpaid medical bills.
But those predictions also proved misguided. The Affordable Care Act was never repealed, and the healthcare sector continued growing in 2017.
On the other side of the political aisle, investors were equally mistaken about the benefits they expected from Joe Biden’s election in 2020. Following Biden’s victory, marijuana stocks soared with some stocks up more than 100% as investors anticipated that Democratic leadership would quickly loosen federal restrictions on cannabis.
Unfortunately for those investors, the anticipated reforms did not materialize nearly as quickly as expected. By February 2021, the rally had begun to reverse, and by August 2022, cannabis companies had collectively lost approximately 73% of their value from their earlier peaks.
I don’t provide these illustrations as proof that election results don’t matter to Wall Street. Government policies absolutely can influence the profitability of individual businesses and entire industries.
Rather, they demonstrate that even when you’re right about which political party will win an election, you can still be spectacularly wrong about what that victory will mean for your investments. After all, if there’s one thing more difficult than predicting what a stock will do, it’s predicting what a politician will do once in power.
(Past performance is no guarantee of future results. The advice is general in nature and not intended for specific situations)